Get Your Quote

Acrylic vs Fiberglass Showers: What’s the Difference?

Choosing the right shower for your bathroom can be tricky, especially when you’re deciding between acrylic and fiberglass. Both options have their pros and cons, and each offers a different look and feel. 

Let’s break down what makes acrylic and fiberglass showers unique, so you can pick the one that’s perfect for your space!

What’s an Acrylic Shower?

Acrylic showers are made from sheets of acrylic, a type of plastic, which are heated and molded into the shape of a shower. These sheets are often reinforced with fiberglass to make them sturdier. Once molded, the surface is smooth, shiny, and durable. Acrylic showers come in a variety of colors and styles, so you have a lot of choices when it comes to customizing your bathroom.

Benefits of Acrylic Showers

  • Durable: Acrylic is known for being pretty tough. It resists scratches and stains better than fiberglass, so it keeps its shine for a long time.
  • Low Maintenance: The non-porous surface of acrylic means it doesn’t absorb water, making it less prone to mold and mildew buildup.
  • Warm to the Touch: Unlike some materials that can feel cold, acrylic retains heat well. This makes it feel warmer when you step in.
  • Easy to Repair: If you do happen to scratch your acrylic shower, it’s fairly easy to fix with a repair kit.

Downsides of Acrylic Showers

  • Cost: Acrylic showers can be pricier than fiberglass. While not as expensive as tile or stone, they’re still a step up in price compared to fiberglass.
  • Installation: Acrylic showers can be a bit trickier to install, especially larger or custom designs. You might need a professional to get it set up just right.

What’s a Fiberglass Shower?

Fiberglass showers are made from layers of reinforced plastic with a gel coating on top. This coating gives it a nice finish but is generally thinner than acrylic. Fiberglass showers are usually lighter and less expensive than acrylic, making them a popular choice for budget-friendly bathroom updates.

Benefits of Fiberglass Showers

  • Budget-Friendly: Fiberglass showers are often the more affordable option, which makes them appealing if you’re working with a limited budget.
  • Lightweight: Fiberglass is lighter than acrylic, so it’s easier to move around and install. This is helpful if you’re planning a DIY project.

Downsides of Fiberglass Showers

  • Durability Issues: Fiberglass can scratch and stain more easily than acrylic, and once it’s scratched, it can be harder to fix. The gel coating is thinner, which makes it less resistant to damage.
  • Not as Long-Lasting: Over time, fiberglass showers can lose their shine and may start to fade or discolor, especially if exposed to heavy use or harsh cleaning chemicals.

Comparing the Look and Feel

When it comes to the look of acrylic vs. fiberglass, there’s a noticeable difference in finish and texture. Acrylic has a glossy, smooth finish that gives it a high-end look. This sleek, shiny finish can make a bathroom look polished and modern. 

Fiberglass, while still nice looking, tends to have a more matte or less glossy finish. It can look great, but doesn’t have quite the same “pop” as acrylic.

Acrylic Showers: Sleek, glossy, and polished. Perfect if you want a more modern, clean look.

Fiberglass Showers: Matte finish, a bit more subdued. Ideal for a casual, budget-friendly bathroom.

Comparing the Look and Feel

When it comes to cleaning, both acrylic and fiberglass are relatively low-maintenance, but there are some differences.
Material Cleaning Features Cleaning Tips
Acrylic
  • Resistant to mold and mildew due to its smooth, non-porous surface.
  • Low-maintenance.
  • Use non-abrasive cleaners with a soft cloth or sponge.
  • Avoid harsh chemicals and abrasive scrubbers to prevent scratches.
Fiberglass
  • Easy to clean but prone to staining if not maintained.
  • Gel coating can wear down over time.
  • Use gentle cleaners and a soft cloth or sponge.
  • Avoid rough scrubbing and harsh chemicals to protect the gel coating.

Cost and Longevity

If budget is your main concern, fiberglass showers are generally cheaper. They’re a good option if you want a quick, affordable bathroom update. However, while acrylic showers might cost a bit more upfront, they’re usually a better investment for the long term due to their durability.
Material Cost Durability
Acrylic Showers Higher upfront cost Lasts longer and stays looking good with minimal wear
Fiberglass Showers Lower upfront cost May need replacement or more repairs over time

Making the Choice: Acrylic vs. Fiberglass Shower

Deciding between acrylic and fiberglass really comes down to your needs, budget, and personal preference. Here’s a quick recap to help you choose:

Choose Acrylic if… you want a durable, glossy shower that’s available in many styles and can handle regular use without showing too much wear.

Choose Fiberglass if… you’re looking for an affordable, lightweight option that’s easy to install, especially if you’re not as concerned about long-term durability.

FAQs

Acrylic generally lasts longer than fiberglass because it’s more resistant to scratches and stains.
Not at all. Both acrylic and fiberglass are easy to clean with mild soap and water, but fiberglass might stain over time if not maintained.
Yes, small scratches in acrylic can usually be buffed out or fixed with a repair kit.
Fiberglass is typically more affordable than acrylic, making it a good option if you’re on a tight budget.
Yes, acrylic retains warmth better, so it feels cozier during a shower.

Wrapping Up: Which Shower is Right for You?

Both acrylic and fiberglass showers have their strengths. Acrylic is durable, easy to clean, and comes in many styles, but it’s more expensive. Fiberglass, on the other hand, is budget-friendly and lightweight, though it may not hold up as well over time.

If you’re ready to upgrade your bathroom with the perfect shower, reach out to Baileys Remodeling! We can help you choose and install the best option for your home, so you get the look and function you want. Contact us today to get started on your bathroom remodeling project and create a space you’ll love for years to come! (919) 986-6162